wk, I couldn't disagree more.
If Nash was so good, why didn't he look this good in Dallas? Nash was a very good player but he looks GREAT in D'Antoni's system -- Nash was the perfect player for D'Antoni's system and Nash was smart enough to recognize it (it didn't help that Cuban was an IDIOT by offending Nash and making him go away).
Well for one he had a big guy who can run the pick and roll that ATTACKS the rim in Amare Stoudamire. You pair Nash's play making ability with Dwight Howard and you get the same result. Heck Kenyon Martin from his Nets days would have been better suited for Nash's passing skills then Dirk. Instead of running a pick and pop for Dirk he was able to deliver bounce passes to a guy who can jump up to the roof and come back down.
Second..the Mavs were about as successful as the Suns were. Great regular season teams, not so great in the playoffs. Neither won the title. Neither were able to get out of the WC under Nash.
D'Antoni saw the writing on the wall -- he was getting the blame (from others AND from Kerr) for not finding a way to deliver a championship to Phoenix with the arrival of Shaq.
I don't disagree with him leaving PHX. I disagree with him passing up the Bulls for New York. Mainly because the players in Chicago are closer to the types of players he wants then guys like Zach Randolph and Eddie Curry. On top of that if he was upset about getting blamed for things why in the hell would he move to New York where the media is rabid, fickle, and down right nasty at times?
Hello, there wasn't a person out there (other than Rick) who thought that Shaq's arrival was anything other than a quicker way out of the playoffs. I really thought they would find a way to challenge the Spurs but they couldn't even do that. Kerr was getting more and more involved in the coaching in Phoenix and D'Antoni understood what that meant -- it's almost like Kerr is looking over his shoulder like Isaiah Thomas did to Brown "I can do that better" -- Kerr can't.
His style of basketball is not going to win a championship. It'll put butts in the seats but it won't win the title. I don't agree with Kerr trying to play coach from the GM spot ala Pat Riley in Miami. At the same time changes did need to be made. Getting Shaq wasn't the answer obviously.
All that said, D'Antoni has got to be kidding himself if he thinks that Phoenix would EVER take back Marbury. Every team that has traded him would never take him back again. I understand that he WANTS them -- he just should understand that this kind of trade is ridiculous and even Kerr is smart enough to know it won't work.
Why would the Suns go out of their way to help D'Antoni? Just doesn't make sense.
The Knicks need to phase out their current contracts -- develop some young talent -- trade for young talent and draft picks, when possible and rebuild. Unless Walsh finds a sucker, he isn't going to get someone for nothing -- that only happens once in a couple of decades (and the Lakers already got it this decade).
D'Antoni doesn't develop young talent or a bench. Before someone shouts out Barbosa, D'Antoni def put his mark on him, he's excellent in the regular season and goes bye bye in the playoffs