Author Topic: McNabb  (Read 1249 times)

Offline Reality

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 8738
    • View Profile
    • Email
McNabb
« on: September 29, 2005, 11:17:48 AM »
How are you Eagles dealing with this news?

PHILADELPHIA -- Donovan McNabb tossed touchdown passes on a broken ankle and played an NFC title game with an agonizing rib injury.

Now McNabb is taking his biggest health risk yet: playing with a severe abdominal strain that likely will need surgery and definitely will leave the five-time Pro Bowl quarterback in discomfort and pain all season.

"Fortunately for me, I haven't got to the point where you just can't go," the Eagles' star said. "Once that happens, then I think the best way of handling this is not being out there. But I don't think that would ever happen."

Trainer Rick Burkholder said rest will not fix the problem and McNabb can play if he can handle the pain. McNabb, who practiced Wednesday, does not have to be sidelined now for the sports hernia.

"We're hoping it's something we'll be able to manage," Burkholder said. "The plan with Donovan is to allow him to participate, continue to rehabilitate him and we're going to take it on a day-by-day, game-by-game situation."

McNabb is expected to start Sunday against Kansas City and is willing to play through his various injuries. McNabb also is playing with soreness in his chest and a shin contusion.

"I'm ready to go," McNabb said Wednesday. "I don't have any concerns right now. ... It's just something you have to deal with and realize some days you'll feel great and some days you won't."

McNabb was tested last week for the sports hernia, but coach Andy Reid called the injury an abdominal strain after the Eagles' win over Oakland. McNabb went to Boston on Tuesday for another opinion and it was confirmed he has a sports hernia.

"His pain may get worse, it may get better, the condition won't," Burkholder said. "It's not like he's going to do a career-ending problem to his abdomen or his groin."

McNabb hoped to delay surgery. Burkholder said it usually takes eight to 12 weeks to recover from that type of surgery.

"If I can avoid it, I definitely will avoid it," McNabb said. "If that's the case that I have to have it, then it will happen."

McNabb didn't know when he first hurt the area. He came into training camp with soreness in his abdomen. He seemed to be fine until the second game against San Francisco, when the injury was aggravated.

The injury hasn't affected McNabb's performance too much. Against the 49ers, he matched his career best with five TD passes and threw for 342 yards while playing three quarters.

Against the Raiders, McNabb rebounded from a slow first half and finished with 365 yards passing and two touchdowns while throwing a career-high 52 passes.

"If it ends up where he can't function, then we'll shut him down," Reid said.

While Reid said he would be smart with how he handles McNabb, he wouldn't rule out another 50-attempt game if that's needed to win.

"If it means throwing 50 times, then you throw 50 times," Reid said.

McNabb has played through pain in the past. He broke his ankle in the first quarter against Arizona in 2002, stayed in and threw four touchdowns.

He had trouble playing with an injured thumb in 2003, but didn't miss any time. In the same year, he suffered a serious rib injury against Carolina in the NFC championship game.

"It's good that I've been in the situation before where I've dealt with pain, I've dealt with soreness, dealt with injuries," McNabb said.

Eagles cornerback Sheldon Brown played with the same injury two years ago and didn't miss any games, though he would miss the occasional series in practice.

"It's like someone's sticking you," he said. "I played with it for a while and actually made it through the season, so it's not that bad."

Also, Reid said kicker David Akers will miss the game against the Chiefs because of a torn hamstring.

Akers originally strained his hamstring during two weeks ago against San Francisco and went down again after redoing the opening kickoff against the Raiders. He returned to make two extra points and kicked the winning field goal in the final seconds.

 

rickortreat

  • Guest
McNabb
« Reply #1 on: September 29, 2005, 11:46:07 AM »
I think that it's up to McNabb and what he wants to do.  His long-term well being is more important than goals for the team.

Since they say, he can still be effective with the injury, and he obviously can.  He's making a choice to play and help the team win.

If he goes out and has surgery, he's trusting that Detmer or McMahon will do well enough that he can return and help them win a Superbowl.

My guess is that Reid would prefer that Donavan keeps playing, and that Donavan wants to keep playing.  I'm ok with that, but a little nervous that Donovan can't be as effective as he could if he was healthier, and that he might get hurt because he can't escape the ay he used to.  

Offline Reality

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 8738
    • View Profile
    • Email
McNabb
« Reply #2 on: September 29, 2005, 12:12:42 PM »
Bottom line I like their stance that they will take his health on a game by game basis.

Yes Reid is playing it in such a way as he hopes McNabb can finish the season then have surgery.  But he is going to have to have it, right?

rickortreat

  • Guest
McNabb
« Reply #3 on: September 29, 2005, 12:46:38 PM »
That's my understanding, that there is a tear in the abdominal wall, which will reguire surgery.  My guess is that they would like to postphone it until after the season.

It is something of a gamble, since it interferes with his natural throwing motion and his ability to run.  He seemed to adjust well to it in the second half of the Raiders game.