I think this is the wrong decision. He's a young manager (in terms of experience) and the Tigers continue to add the talent he needs to win. He's made some questionable decisions (from a few of the Tigers' games I've seen), but, from what I've read, he's very popular with the players in the clubhouse. He turned around a team that lost the most games in the history of the AL (119 losses in 2003) to a 72-game winner last season. Someone should give him another chance.
