How about choosing an WC and an EC all-star team .

[Guest_Randy]

All-Star starters and one reserve per each position for both conferences?  

Anyone?

[westkoast]

Steve Nash
Kobe Bryant (Should be able to slide down to SF spot)
Ray Allen
Kevin Garnet
Tim Duncan (yes I know hes listed as a forward but should be allowed to slide down to make room for Amare)

I know it doesnt fit the rules but this is how it should be based on games played so far.

Will be back later to do EC.......

[ziggy]

Western Conference

PG  #1  -  Steve Nash
PG  #2  -  Mike Bibby
SG  #1  -  Kobe Bryant
SG  #2  -  Ray Allen
SF  #1  -  Tracy McGrady
SF  #2  -  Shawn Marion
PF  #1  -  Kevin Garnett
PF  #2  -  Dirk Nowitski
C  #1  -  Tim Duncan
C  #2  -  Amare Stoudemire
Additional reserve #1  -  Rashard Lewis
Additional reserve #2  -  Andre Kirilenko (if he can't play then Peja Stojokovic)


Eastern Conference

PG  #1  -  Allen Iverson
PG  #2  -  Gilbert Arenas
SG  #1  -  Dwayne Wade
SG  #2  -  Micheal Redd
SF  #1  -  LeBron James
SF  #2  -  Paul Pierce
PF  #1  -  Ben Wallace
PF  #2  -  Antwan Jamison
C  #1  -  Shaq O'Neal
C  #2  -  Emeka Okafor
Additional reserve #1  -  Grant Hill  (he probably doesn't deserve to play, but he has earned the right to play)
Additional reserve #2  -  Larry Hughes

 

[WayOutWest]

You need to follow the rules.

WC
G: Kobe
G: Nash
F: Dirk
F: KG
C: Yao

Reserves
TD, AK, Amare, Marion, T-Mac, Allen & B. Miller

EC
G: Wade
G: James
F: Jamison
F: JO
C: Shaq

Reserves
Iverson, Pierce, Redd, B. Wallace, Hamilton, A. Walker & G. Hill

[westkoast]

You need to follow the rules.

WC
G: Kobe
G: Nash
F: Dirk
F: KG
C: Yao

Reserves
TD, AK, Amare, Marion, T-Mac, Allen & B. Miller

EC
G: Wade
G: James
F: Jamison
F: JO
C: Shaq

Reserves
Iverson, Pierce, Redd, B. Wallace, Hamilton, A. Walker & G. Hill

Says who?  We arent really voting here.  The system is flawed because guys like Steve Nash, Kobe Bryant, and Ray Allen all deserve to start.  Randy said based on performance.  

[Guest_Randy]

Umm, we do have to follow the NBA ballots, here:

Two G positions, Two F positions and One C position in both conferences:

Western Conference:
  G:  Steve Nash
  G:  Kobe Bryant
  F:   KG
  F:   Dirk
  C:  Yao

Back-ups:
  G: Ray Allen  
  G: TMac
  F:  Kirilenko
  F:  TD (Wow, can you believe he is coming off the bench this year?)
  C:  BRad

Reserve 1:  Amare Stoudamire
Reserve 2:  Marion

Eastern Conference:
  G: Wade
  G: LeBron James
  F:  Jamison
  F:  O'Neal
  C:  Shaq

Back-ups:
  G: Arenas
  G: AI
  F:  Jefferson
  F:  Okafor
  C: Ben Wallace

Reserve 1:  Grant Hill
Reserve 2:  Larry Hughes (Can't believe I just typed that)


It's REALLY hard to imagine TD coming off the bench -- but IMO, both Dirk and KG are having better years than TD -- the toughest choices in the whole All-Star process!!!